Getty Images

Buemi shaping up as best candidate for Toro Rosso F1 seat at COTA


Sebastien Buemi is shaping up as the leading candidate to race for Toro Rosso in next weekend’s United States Grand Prix as the Formula 1 team searches for a driver to replace Pierre Gasly.

Toro Rosso announced last week that Gasly would be joined by the returning Daniil Kvyat for the remaining four races of the season following Carlos Sainz Jr.’s early move to Renault.

Gasly made his F1 debut with Toro Rosso in Malaysia after Daniil Kvyat was dropped due to poor form, but uncertainty quickly arose surrounding his participation at the Circuit of The Americas due to the clash with the Super Formula finale at Suzuka on October 22, where the Frenchman is Honda’s sole title contender.

Red Bull team advisor Helmut Marko said last weekend the announcement was a “mistake”, with reports from multiple outlets emerging on Thursday claiming that Gasly would not be featuring in Austin.

Toro Rosso is short on options for a replacement given FIA Super Licence requirements, leading to Toyota LMP1 and Renault Formula E driver Buemi entering the mix.

Buemi raced in F1 for Toro Rosso between 2009 and 2011 before being dropped to make way for Daniel Ricciardo and Jean-Eric Vergne, prompting the Swiss driver to link up with Toyota in the FIA World Endurance Championship.

Buemi won the WEC title in 2014 and became Formula E champion in 2016 with Renault, giving him more than triple the required 40 Super Licence points to race in F1.

Despite losing his Toro Rosso seat at the end of 2011, Buemi retained his links to Red Bull, and recently completed running in its 2017-spec F1 car in a Pirelli tire test.

Asked directly at Suzuka if Buemi could return, Marko remained coy, saying: “With Red Bull, anything is possible.”

Besides Buemi, Toro Rosso is short on options for drivers to replace Gasly, with no other racers inside the Red Bull family meeting the required Super Licence criteria to step in.

Porsche WEC racer Brendon Hartley was linked to the seat by multiple sources to NBC Sports, with the New Zealander still boasting ties to Red Bull despite being dropped from its junior program at the end of 2010.

Hartley has raced with Porsche since 2014 and claimed the WEC drivers’ championship in 2015 to give him the 40 points required for a Super Licence.

Hartley won this year’s 24 Hours of Le Mans and is expected to return to single-seaters next year in the Verizon IndyCar Series with Chip Ganassi Racing upon the closure of Porsche’s LMP1 program.

However, Hartley does not fulfill the Super Licence criteria as he has not completed 300 km in an F1 car from the past four seasons, with his last F1 test coming back in 2012 with Mercedes.

Hartley’s travel schedule also is problematic. He won last weekend in Atlanta at Motul Petit Le Mans in a Nissan Onroak DPi on Saturday, and would then have needed to travel shortly thereafter to the WEC event in Fuji this weekend.

So unless a narrow window appears to complete a private test to rack up the required mileage between now and the start of on-track running at COTA, he is not an option.

Red Bull has not hired a driver from outside of its own umbrella since signing four-time Champ Car champion Sebastien Bourdais to Toro Rosso back in 2008, making a change in approach now seem unlikely.

However, the team may have no choice but to if it is keen on finding a driver to evaluate for a 2018 F1 seat, potentially to partner Gasly and replace the struggling Kvyat.

The 2016 Indianapolis 500 winner Alexander Rossi is a favorite son of Honda, who will become Toro Rosso’s F1 engine supplier next year, and would be a popular fan option for the U.S. race, as he was in 2015 when he last competed with Manor. However, the American is currently out of the country, believed to be filming TV show The Amazing Race.

Another Honda-linked driver is Formula 2’s Nobuharu Matsushita, but the Japanese youngster falls way short of having the required Super Licence points to be a viable option.

As noted in a report by Auto Motor und Sport, Renault youngster Sergey Sirotkin could be a candidate as he has the required Super Licence points and could offer financial backing from the Russian SMP Racing program.

Renault has already confirmed Nico Hulkenberg and Carlos Sainz Jr. for 2018, cutting off Sirotkin’s most obvious route into F1, but Toro Rosso could yet become an alternative were deal to be struck.

Regardless of who steps in for the Austin F1 race, Toro Rosso will be unable to use any additional drivers this year due to the FIA-imposed limit of four per season.

Buemi has no clashes between now and the end of the F1 season, with upcoming WEC races in Shanghai and Bahrain falling between the grands prix in Mexico, Brazil and Abu Dhabi.

Gasly is set to return following his appearance in the Super Formula finale for the final three races of the season as he makes a case for a full-time drive with Toro Rosso in 2018.

As per the previously cited report from Auto Motor und Sport, a decision will be taken by Red Bull and Toro Rosso on Tuesday.

Neurosurgeon discusses brain injuries such as Michael Schumacher’s

Getty Images
1 Comment

PARIS (AP) — More than four years after a ski accident caused him a near-fatal brain injury, little is known about Michael Schumacher’s current condition. Updates on his health have been extremely scarce ever since he left hospital in September 2014 to be cared for privately at his Swiss home on the shores of Lake Geneva. Details of his specific condition and the treatment he received have been kept strictly private. The last public statement 16 months ago clarified nothing further would be said.

Colin Shieff is a retired neurosurgeon from Britain’s National Health Service and a trustee of Headway, the national brain injury charity. Although he has never treated Schumacher, or spoken with doctors who’ve treated Schumacher over the years, he has dealt with similar cases both at immediate critical-care level and further down the line in terms of long-term treatment.

Shieff spent many years working with people with brain injuries and trauma, including at NATO field hospitals in Afghanistan an Iraq. He answered questions for The Associated Press related to the nature of Schumacher’s brain injury, pertaining to how his condition may have evolved in the time since his accident.

MORE: As F1 season begins, Michael Schumacher still fighting, far from forgotten

Q. In your opinion, what’s the likely prognosis at this stage?

A. “The nature of his injury and those bits of information that are available, and have been available, suggest that he has sustained permanent and very major damage to his brain. As a consequence his brain does not function in a fashion similar to yours or mine. The longer one goes on after an injury the more remote it is that any improvement becomes. He is almost certainly not going to change from the situation he is now.”

Q. What ongoing treatments would he be having?

A. “He will have the kind of treatment, which is care: giving him nourishment, giving him fluid. The probability is that this is given in the main – or at least as supplements – through some tube passed into his intestinal system, either through his nose or mouth, or more likely a tube in the front wall of the tummy. He will have therapy to sit him, because he won’t be able to get himself out of a bed and into a chair. He will be treated in a way that will ensure his limbs move and don’t remain rigid.”

Q. Would someone in his position receive around-the-clock treatment?

A. “He will be allowed a period of rest and sleep and relaxation, and he will be given an environment. I’m positive as I can be without knowing the facts (that) he will be living in an environment that – although it’s got artificial bits of medical kit and care and people – will mimic a caring, warm, pleasant, socially stimulating environment.”

Q. Would he be able to sense he’s in such an environment?

A. “I don’t know. There is always a technical, medical and neurological issue with defining a coma. Almost certainly he cannot express himself (in a conversation). He may well be able to indicate, or it may be apparent to those around him, that he is uncomfortable or unhappy. Or (he) is perhaps getting pleasure from seeing his children or hearing music he’s always liked, or having his hand stroked.”

Q. Are patients in his situation aware of touch and voice from family members?

A. “Absolutely. Even in the early stages, even in a critical care unit, when medicines are being given, for one individual at one time there may be an ability to discern and show response to someone they are familiar with. Respond to familiar, respond to family you’re triggered to. You hear them all your life so that’s the very, very familiar (aspect) the person is going to respond to.”

Q. Is there a chance he can make A) a full recovery? B) A partial recovery?

A. “First one, absolutely, totally no. Number one statistically, number two neurologically, and number three he’s been ill for so long. He’s lost muscle bulk, even if he opened his eyes and started talking there will have been loss of memory, there will be impact on behavior, on cognitive functions. He would not be the same person. (As for a) partial recovery, even the smallest thing that gets better is some kind of recovery. But (it depends) whether that recovery contributes to a functional improvement for him to be able to express himself – other than an evidence of saying `Yes’ or an evidence of saying `No.’ (Therefore) if he could use words of two syllables, if he could turn on the remote control for the tele. One can do, professionally, all sorts of wonderful things with electronic devices and couple them up to eye and mouth movements. Sometimes with a person in a situation called `Locked In’ or `Profoundly neurologically comprised’ – which is essentially paralysis but with continuing intellectual function – ways can be found to communicate with those people. If that had been so with Michael Schumacher I am positive we would have known that is the case, so I don’t believe it’s so for him.”

Q. This is a deeply personal decision for the family. But how long can treatment last for?

A. “In, for example, our health system we don’t have the luxury to keep maximal intervention going in a high-tech hospital environment. For Michael Schumacher’s family, I suspect they have the financial support to be able to provide those things. Therefore, for him, the future is longer but it doesn’t imply any change in the quality of it.”

Q. Some reports have estimated the cost of treatment at anything up to 200,000 euros ($245,000) per week. Is that realistic?

A. “I would personally think that’s over the top, in terms of what I reckon that might buy him. He’ll have a nurse, a therapist, a visiting doctor. There’ll be an extra pair of hands when something physical is being done, when he’s being moved to somewhere. That doesn’t add up to 150,000 euros or 200,000 euros. He needs essentially, somebody with nursing or therapeutic qualifications with him at all times. So that’s however many people you need to run a 24/7 roster. You’re talking probably eight people to provide that level of care constantly over a year’s period. That’s the number of nurses required for instance, to nurse or to staff, one critical care bed in an intensive care unit.”

More AP auto racing:


For further details on Headway: